Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 292
Listener-supported — Commercial-free
share
tweet
Comments (215)add comment
joejennings wrote:
I Agree completely! I was also 17yrs old when this came out! I played it so much that I wore it out & had to buy a new one! GREAT ALBUM!! Thanx RP!
RP, Thank You for the lyrics. For many years, I got them wrong. I have listened to this on RP at least 10 times while reading the lyrics & remembering what I thought they were. NOW I have to figure out what they mean! LOL!
I Agree completely! I was also 17yrs old when this came out! I played it so much that I wore it out & had to buy a new one! GREAT ALBUM!! Thanx RP!
RP, Thank You for the lyrics. For many years, I got them wrong. I have listened to this on RP at least 10 times while reading the lyrics & remembering what I thought they were. NOW I have to figure out what they mean! LOL!
That is an excellent synthesizer solo Close To The End of the song.
SomersetBob wrote:
I Agree completely! I was also 17yrs old when this came out! I played it so much that I wore it out & had to buy a new one! GREAT ALBUM!! Thanx RP!
I see quite a few negative comments have been made down the years about this one - so I will just add a bit of balance by saying I love it as much now as when I first heard it 46 years ago when I was - dear god, 17! - and I thank Bill and Radio Paradise so much for playing it.
I Agree completely! I was also 17yrs old when this came out! I played it so much that I wore it out & had to buy a new one! GREAT ALBUM!! Thanx RP!
I got to see the 50th anniversary performance of this song and album on 10-25-22 in a small theater with my 13 y/o son and it was quite magical. That was probably the last time I'll get to see them perform. 1st time was "in the round" at Madison Square Garden in 1980 and at least a dozen other times in between those two. Their music fills me with joy.
sfoster66 wrote:
Well, at least you listened to it in it's entirety! Everybody has different tastes. I love BOTH bands, and I have, since the 70s!
Unfortunately for the unregainable last 17 minutes of my life, I have come to the conclusion that I fall into the Genesis camp when it comes to the whole Prog Rock genre. No Yes, no.
Well, at least you listened to it in it's entirety! Everybody has different tastes. I love BOTH bands, and I have, since the 70s!
FlatCat wrote:
Everybody has different tastes. I think they are GREAT!!! ...Noodle on!
I just realized why I've never like Yes. Just like Wagner! No cadences for measures and measures. Meandering, noodling melodic line.
Everybody has different tastes. I think they are GREAT!!! ...Noodle on!
FlatCat wrote:
As Flat as the Cat?
I just realized why I've never like Yes. Just like Wagner! No cadences for measures and measures. Meandering, noodling melodic line.
As Flat as the Cat?
Vicey wrote:
Those are the best songs!
I took my oldest son to see one of the two Yes bands now touring. They opened with this. Ten minutes in he turns to me and asks "Is this still the same song?"
Those are the best songs!
GODLIKE!!!
I just realized why I've never like Yes. Just like Wagner! No cadences for measures and measures. Meandering, noodling melodic line.
Crazy good. To me, It's like one's life would be exposed in one song. All these instruments, rythmes, voices
Yes is clearly out of the box
Unfortunately for the unregainable last 17 minutes of my life, I have come to the conclusion that I fall into the Genesis camp when it comes to the whole Prog Rock genre. No Yes, no.
This appears to be almost, if not THE, most polarizing song in the RP catalog. Curious. However, it is wildly experimental and quite long, so I can understand that it is grating to a lot of folks.
Steely_D contends: Les Claypool should've replaced Squire.
westslope wrote:
Better than Geddy Lee?
I think Geddy's at the end of his time, but Claypool has a lot more ahead. And he would've been so experimental, which would've helped the band. The current stuff is so pedestrian.
westslope wrote:
Better than Geddy Lee?
I think Geddy's at the end of his time, but Claypool has a lot more ahead. And he would've been so experimental, which would've helped the band. The current stuff is so pedestrian.
Yes - Please.
This was one of the albums that kept me sane and happy whilst learning my trade with Shell in the 70's.
Thank (any) god it existed, now I have to deal with Rap, Hip Hop and goodness knows how many other forms of 'music' that should have been aborted.
This was one of the albums that kept me sane and happy whilst learning my trade with Shell in the 70's.
Thank (any) god it existed, now I have to deal with Rap, Hip Hop and goodness knows how many other forms of 'music' that should have been aborted.
It has been a while since I put this one on the turntable and I'd sorta forgotten what hot stuff it really is. All those years, still is.
I think it's safe to say that Covid and all the politics that surround it, have put us all close to the edge for the past year and a half. Thanks to RP for keeping us from going over it. ; )
stanohlohovec5 wrote:
It is well known about the band Yes that you either love them or damn them ... I have loved them always..
I think you could say that about the entirety of progressive rock. People openly mock its excesses but fail to mention the virtuosity. Love it.
It is well known about the band Yes that you either love them or damn them ... I have loved them always..
I think you could say that about the entirety of progressive rock. People openly mock its excesses but fail to mention the virtuosity. Love it.
It‘s a 10 because I love to hear it every time and because it reminds me why I spend money to have station like this. Music you hardly will find at any radio station. Real music. Hand made.
It is just pure brilliance!!
avereaiii590 wrote:
It is well known about the band Yes that you either love them or damn them ... I have loved them always..
Funny, looking at the ratings, listeners either hate it or love it.
Count me in with the loves, remember the day this album came out.
Guess you had to be there.
Count me in with the loves, remember the day this album came out.
Guess you had to be there.
It is well known about the band Yes that you either love them or damn them ... I have loved them always..
Steely_D wrote:
Better than Geddy Lee?
LISTEN to that bass at the beginning.
I still contend that Les Claypool should've replaced Squire.
Better than Geddy Lee?
westslope wrote:
It is absolutely fantastic. It is true...
Talk Talk followed by Yes.
C'est absolument fantastique.
It is absolutely fantastic. It is true...
Funny, looking at the ratings, listeners either hate it or love it.
Count me in with the loves, remember the day this album came out.
Guess you had to be there.
Count me in with the loves, remember the day this album came out.
Guess you had to be there.
I have tried so hard to enjoy Yes. I think it's his voice? But I must say, their lyrics are something to behold so for that I do appreciate the band.
simple: 10/10 
No.
Talk Talk followed by Yes.
C'est absolument fantastique.
C'est absolument fantastique.
LISTEN to that bass at the beginning.
I still contend that Les Claypool should've replaced Squire.
I still contend that Les Claypool should've replaced Squire.
The song is over. Nappy time.
Wow.
I need some microdot or orange sunshine or window pane for this!!!!
Yikes.
I need some microdot or orange sunshine or window pane for this!!!!
Yikes.
mgkiwi wrote:
Hey man, it's cosmic. Takes some time and get cosmic.
ENOUGH ALREADY!!!!! 
Hey man, it's cosmic. Takes some time and get cosmic.
I apologize for repeating myself in the course of two minutes.
But for crying out loud....this song is just freakin amazing.
And that bass. Oh the bass.
My last question: was this song recorded in one session? I don't hear how they could piece together short tracks into one big track. But that would be impossible, eh!
Eh! Eh! Eh!
Time to drive back to the dispeniary, again
But for crying out loud....this song is just freakin amazing.
And that bass. Oh the bass.
My last question: was this song recorded in one session? I don't hear how they could piece together short tracks into one big track. But that would be impossible, eh!
Eh! Eh! Eh!
Time to drive back to the dispeniary, again
ENOUGH ALREADY!!!!!
A LOAD OF SELF INDULGENT CRAP!!!
A LOAD OF SELF INDULGENT CRAP!!! Is it Egads!
Is it Gadzooks?
Is it WTF?
It's...it's...it's...pandemonium!!!!
It's....it's....Chris Squire at his freakin best!!!!
And Steve Howe ain't bad either.
Is it Gadzooks?
Is it WTF?
It's...it's...it's...pandemonium!!!!
It's....it's....Chris Squire at his freakin best!!!!
And Steve Howe ain't bad either.
Thanks for reminding me why I never liked YES 
CRAP!!
CRAP!!Had to switch to my better headphones. Oooow, that's MUCH better.
10, now and forever.
10, now and forever.
drewd wrote:
Damn.. this is a long song
Damn.. this is a long song
You are right, this is a song as opposed to Long Strange Golden Road (The Waterboys)!
I think I'm slightly embarrassed for RP listeners that this has a 6.7 rating?! One of the greatest prog rock songs ever written. If this is not a 9 or 10 what is?
MLavender wrote:
Interesting that you say you've heard a lot of prog rock and list great bands that I love too, because this is like the definition, the foundation, the pinnacle even, of prog rock, imho. Maybe you had to be there.
But... I was there and as someone else just posted... it was sublime. Bruford's sophisticated drumming, Squire ripping his bass like it was a lead guitar, Anderson's unique and soaring vocals, Wakeman and Howe laying down licks that make your head spin, all meshing perfectly minute after glorious minute. Their sheer musicianship and ability to make the complex accessible to my young and impressionable mind was mind blowing. - it made most 3 minute, 3 chord radio songs pale by comparison. Then, when I started playing music myself, my appreciation for just how friggn hard that stuff is to play, allowed it to stay fresh for me. Solid 10 from me.
Seems that everyone that likes this has fond memories of it from the 70s. I don't think this has aged well or appeals across generations. I love some prog rock (Pink Floyd, Porcupine Tree, Tangerine Dream), but this gets a 2 from me.
Maybe if I hadn't heard a lot more prog rock before hearing this, I might like it more.
Interesting that you say you've heard a lot of prog rock and list great bands that I love too, because this is like the definition, the foundation, the pinnacle even, of prog rock, imho. Maybe you had to be there.
But... I was there and as someone else just posted... it was sublime. Bruford's sophisticated drumming, Squire ripping his bass like it was a lead guitar, Anderson's unique and soaring vocals, Wakeman and Howe laying down licks that make your head spin, all meshing perfectly minute after glorious minute. Their sheer musicianship and ability to make the complex accessible to my young and impressionable mind was mind blowing. - it made most 3 minute, 3 chord radio songs pale by comparison. Then, when I started playing music myself, my appreciation for just how friggn hard that stuff is to play, allowed it to stay fresh for me. Solid 10 from me.
Pretty good keyboard solo, eh?
Sublime...
Seems that everyone that likes this has fond memories of it from the 70s. I don't think this has aged well or appeals across generations. I love some prog rock (Pink Floyd, Porcupine Tree, Tangerine Dream), but this gets a 2 from me.
Maybe if I hadn't heard a lot more prog rock before hearing this, I might like it more.
Hey guys, I think I'm having a Friday Freakout! YES!
I'm on the side of the most positive comments. At the same time I was immersed in Yes's music, Roger Dean's cover art pleased my eyes almost as much the music pleased my ears. Easily the most cerebral band of its day.
aroma wrote:
Kudos to RP! What other station dials up 17 minute gems like Close to the Edge, playing them from end to end?
Well, all I can say is, when I lived in TX, there were 2 "main" rock stations...one played songs, the other played album sides....that was pretty cool. njswede wrote:
Absolutely admire the artistry and craftsmanship in prog rock. I grew up with it and then grew out of it and expanded my musical tastes into other genres. 17 minutes of scales and solos aren't really my thing anymore and I now find it impossible to listen to it. This is music for musicians, of which I am one so I can appreciate it for the technical ability, not for most people of which I am also most people. It will go down as a classic as will Born to Be Wild, Smoke on the Water, Sweet Home Alabama, et al. If I never hear those songs again, it certainly won't cause me the same discomfort it is to listen to this song as well as those. Hope that helps.
I would love to understand what's going on in the minds of people who give this a one. Maybe it's not your style, I get that, but one has to admire the musical artistry and craftsmanship on this track!
Absolutely admire the artistry and craftsmanship in prog rock. I grew up with it and then grew out of it and expanded my musical tastes into other genres. 17 minutes of scales and solos aren't really my thing anymore and I now find it impossible to listen to it. This is music for musicians, of which I am one so I can appreciate it for the technical ability, not for most people of which I am also most people. It will go down as a classic as will Born to Be Wild, Smoke on the Water, Sweet Home Alabama, et al. If I never hear those songs again, it certainly won't cause me the same discomfort it is to listen to this song as well as those. Hope that helps.
Wow that takes me back... to High School. It was mindblowing then and still is.
One of the first concerts I saw was Yes before they hit the arenas. Gad I'm old. I just looked it up - Sept 23 1972. They played bits of this, and older stuff.
One of the first concerts I saw was Yes before they hit the arenas. Gad I'm old. I just looked it up - Sept 23 1972. They played bits of this, and older stuff.
Big fan in the '70s, still appreciate the talent but times and tastes change. They need to be listened to - and today perhaps I just don't have the inclination
I remember I invited a girl from university to a concert in a huge hall, hoping she would like Yes ... and consequently me too. 
Unfortunately, as soon as they started playing, the sound was so loud and overwhelming we had to leave the place quickly, and she was really really mad at me. Duh
Unfortunately, as soon as they started playing, the sound was so loud and overwhelming we had to leave the place quickly, and she was really really mad at me. Duh
The bass on this song is amaizing. Squire was the best ever. RIP
I'm just amazed that after almost 50 years since I first heard this, I still like listening for the same reasons. It's a soaring, orchestrated journey into another time and place. Their concerts back then were the physical manifestation, down to the dry ice pouring off the stage. It was all like a dream.
bobcanna1 wrote:
Some might object to your criteria for the existence of the Almighty, but I'm with you, bobcanna1. ; )
YES ..... there is a GOD! Thanks, i needed that! a 10 plus!
Some might object to your criteria for the existence of the Almighty, but I'm with you, bobcanna1. ; )Thanks for the spacey memories of yesteryear- better than just about anything around today! They just don't make them like this anymore- unfortunately!
diannemck56 wrote:
48 years later, still sittin' back, headphones on, herbal state of mind. Still fabulous.
Wow! That goes out with a bang!!
As a teen, I wore this album out with hundreds of listens, headphone on, laying across my bed, eyes closed after a little smoke in the field behind our house. It just didn't get much better and it stands the test of time to me. Thank you, Bill for the memories.
48 years later, still sittin' back, headphones on, herbal state of mind. Still fabulous.
Wow! That goes out with a bang!!
No
Listening to this, I want to be Close to the Fridge.
I can respect the artistry, or talent, or whatever, but my guess is this is one of those songs that is more fun to play than to listen to. Props to them for pushing the boundaries and taking chances!
njswede wrote:
I give it a one. Because when you are at work and have to concentrate this music is simply too much and very annoying! But I agree with your comment. Only there is no rating for musical artistry and craftsmanship. Wish there was!
I would love to understand what's going on in the minds of people who give this a one. Maybe it's not your style, I get that, but one has to admire the musical artistry and craftsmanship on this track!
I give it a one. Because when you are at work and have to concentrate this music is simply too much and very annoying! But I agree with your comment. Only there is no rating for musical artistry and craftsmanship. Wish there was!
super! !!
Re: this kind of music is the primary reason that disco became popular.
sqqqrly wrote:
Gotta wonder if someone saying such a thing is old enough to remember either.
Probably a punk rocker...
sqqqrly wrote:
Gotta wonder if someone saying such a thing is old enough to remember either.
Probably a punk rocker...
Wow, time travelling 44 years back to my earlier self when I was 22.
After Echoes by Pink Floyd, my favourite.
Absolutely beautiful -> 10.
After Echoes by Pink Floyd, my favourite.
Absolutely beautiful -> 10.
I would love to understand what's going on in the minds of people who give this a one. Maybe it's not your style, I get that, but one has to admire the musical artistry and craftsmanship on this track!
The most astonishing stage lighting system I have ever seen. Selland Arena Fresno 1976. 14 with my girlfriend. LOTs of joints being passed around. The light system was a space dinosaur skeleton with three heads that articulated, glowed, lasered - you name it. I didn't smoke but had a contact high. I have never seen anything like it since.
Yes? No!
(anonymous) wrote:
Gotta wonder if someone saying such a thing is old enough to remember either.
please no Yes....this kind of music is the primary reason that disco became popular. 
Gotta wonder if someone saying such a thing is old enough to remember either.
I'm so lucky to be in Bill's timezone. This is one hell of a Friday night party we're having!
Generally I like long songs and find myself routinely asking for more from the 3-5 minute songs. But this would have been nicer at the 8-12 minute length. Extending to 17:44 is a bit too long for me. I still rate it an 8 because it is a great song.
This is one of the songs that late night DJs play when they need to hit the bathroom. That's its only redeeming feature, IMO.
I find the listener ratings on this one most interesting - 12% rating it a "1" and 24% rating it a "10". I'm not always in the mood for Yes, but when I am, I love how immersed I become with their music. One of the reasons that I have always been a Yes fan, is that they were one of the bands that never succumbed to the commercialism of crafting 4-minute songs for AM airplay. For me, artists that craft music because they want to explore and push their own boundaries will always be at the top of the list of artists I admire.
eileenomurphy wrote:
Yes!!!!! The plethora of negative comments is a surprise.
EXTREMELY EXCELLENT! ...Thanx Bill!
Yes!!!!! The plethora of negative comments is a surprise.
Damn.. this is a long song
oh my god how long is this bloody song MAKE IT STOPPPPP
BCarn wrote:
Awesome stuff! Classic.
For those that like Radiohead (but not this) and complain that others "Just don't get it"...same goes here.
For those that like Radiohead (but not this) and complain that others "Just don't get it"...same goes here.
Awesome stuff! Classic.
Seeing some of the negative comments here remind of those about Radiohead. For those that like Radiohead (but not this) and complain that others "Just don't get it"...same goes here. I'd argue it's easier to like this.
Seeing some of the negative comments here remind of those about Radiohead. For those that like Radiohead (but not this) and complain that others "Just don't get it"...same goes here. I'd argue it's easier to like this.
(anonymous) wrote:
Disco became popular because people could dance to it. It still is for that very same reason. End of story.
please no Yes....this kind of music is the primary reason that disco became popular.
Disco became popular because people could dance to it. It still is for that very same reason. End of story.
eileenomurphy wrote:good lord this one goes on a bit to long ......
SnapDragon66 wrote:
The squeaking vocals !
Then go listen to Michael Buble', skippy!
The squeaking vocals !
Then go listen to Michael Buble', skippy!
RParadise wrote:
YOU BET! ...Pete!!! ...WNEW FM 102.7!!! ...Allison Steel "The Night Bird" (late night DJ), on WNEW, used to play this a lot! ...The good old days!!!
In the words of the late, legendary New York DJ Pete Fornatale, "What's not to like?"
YOU BET! ...Pete!!! ...WNEW FM 102.7!!! ...Allison Steel "The Night Bird" (late night DJ), on WNEW, used to play this a lot! ...The good old days!!!
Their sound if one of a kind. The scope of their songs is breathtaking. Love them or hate them; your call. I loved them in the 70s and still do. Saw them in 1976 in Maple Leaf Gardens even though I was fighting a bad case of tonsillitis. Memorable. A 10 with a bullet!
EXTREMELY EXCELLENT! ...Thanx Bill!
Wikipedia wrote:
Close to the Edge is the fifth studio album by English progressive rock band Yes, released on 13 September 1972 by Atlantic Records. It is their last album of the 1970s to feature original drummer Bill Bruford before he left to join King Crimson.
That explains the tiny bit of King Crimson I hear.
Thanks for pulling this out of the archives Bill.
Close to the Edge is the fifth studio album by English progressive rock band Yes, released on 13 September 1972 by Atlantic Records. It is their last album of the 1970s to feature original drummer Bill Bruford before he left to join King Crimson.
That explains the tiny bit of King Crimson I hear.
Thanks for pulling this out of the archives Bill.
IMO, Yes was one of the finest collections of shear creative musical talent ever.. the mixing on this album made all that all so evident. Thanks for playing this, Bill! Queue it up anytime and go make a samwich or something...
...And suddenly I'm 14 again. I can't remember what I went upstairs for, but somehow I still know nearly all of these preposterous lyrics.
A stone cold classic. To me this is the ultimate prog rock song.
RParadise wrote:
The squeaking vocals !
In the words of the late, legendary New York DJ Pete Fornatale, "What's not to like?"
The squeaking vocals !
How can ANYBODY vote this song between 1 & 50 . WTF.
This I think is the most widely spreaded song I ever seen here on RP.
Very Few Classic Rock Songs only rate below 70. This should not be one of them.
This I think is the most widely spreaded song I ever seen here on RP.
Very Few Classic Rock Songs only rate below 70. This should not be one of them.
At their peak in 1973, maybe the most self indulgent group of
all time. However, when Squire , Bruford and Howe connected
they could make magic. "Siberian Khatru" from this album is
a stroke of genius..
all time. However, when Squire , Bruford and Howe connected
they could make magic. "Siberian Khatru" from this album is
a stroke of genius..
Over the edge
...in a good way.
...in a good way.
In the words of the late, legendary New York DJ Pete Fornatale, "What's not to like?"
jahgirl8 wrote:
U standing for?...
We can be anything in front of a green screen.
U standing for?...
We can be anything in front of a green screen.
It has always been quite a special trip.
Even all these years later.
A favorite vinyl album. Then a favorite CD. Now a favorite on Spotify. And I still listen to it intently when this classic plays on RP.
Times change. But I still love this musician's music I grew up with regardless of the media.
Times change. But I still love this musician's music I grew up with regardless of the media.
Huh! This is by far the weirdest rating-graphic of all songs on RP I know. I call it »the U-rating«.
Long life RP however…
Long life RP however…
The ratings for most songs on RP look like a bell curve. This is a saddle! That tells you something.
Heard this today for the first time in decades. Went right to Amazon and bought the Roger Dean album cover book.
Heard this today for the first time in decades. Went right to Amazon and bought the Roger Dean album cover book.
Ich war zwar ca. 1974 mal auf einem Yes-Konzeert, aber ich finde speziell diesen Song heute nur noch schrecklich.
you must be bald?
idiot_wind wrote:
idiot_wind wrote:
Went out and got my haircut.
What I missed?
What I missed?
Jazz on LSD. A ten, of course.
<edit, after it was over> Thanks, BillG and Rebecca. I get up, I get down.
<edit, after it was over> Thanks, BillG and Rebecca. I get up, I get down.
Even as a Yes-fan at the time I thought this was Over The Edge.
Went out and got my haircut.
What I missed?
What I missed?
I have a strange reluctance to hitting PSD on RP. I kinda like the idea that other people may be listening on the other side of the planet to the exact same track as I am. I overcame that long held reluctance about 4 minutes in to this pompous tosh.
A pure prog classic over all !
Thanks for playing this. Brought back fond memories of my teen years too. I've always known Steve Howe was a highly technical player, but didn't every pick up the some of the similarities until my wife came in the room and said "Is this Frank?" (Zappa)
black321 wrote:
yea verily ... me as well.
Can't believe i hadn't yet rated this wonderful, glorious, beautiful piece of music.
yea verily ... me as well.
very innovative and experimental, love yes. you just have to stick to it and listen through...
Fragile I got. This one not so much.
The Union DVD is fantastic though.
The Union DVD is fantastic though.
This is so much more than self-indulgence. It's like the soundtrack to someone actually going about their daily business wanking with a straight face. The world is a better place for this kind of experiment.
Aghhh! I really hate YES!
Now I know why I never bought into Yes - what protracted bollocks!
Hark ! What shite pours from yonder speakers.
I never appreciated Yes that much, until I started listening to RP
Those of us who had the pleasure of attending a Yes concert in the late 70's know...
We just do.
We just do.
Can this about 'Yes`, they never seemed to embrace the concept of `less is more'.
I am glad I'm on the mp3 stream, I would have skipped this long ago and long weird tracks are part of what make RP RP
Still epic.
Wow. Didn't remember how much was going on in this song.
As a teen, I wore this album out with hundreds of listens, headphone on, laying across my bed, eyes closed after a little smoke in the field behind our house. It just didn't get much better and it stands the test of time to me. Thank you, Bill for the memories.
17? oh you kids today.... pretty much agree with you. Saw them twice, each concert about half the stuff was crap and half brilliant. SomersetBob wrote:
I see quite a few negative comments have been made down the years about this one - so I will just add a bit of balance by saying I love it as much now as when I first heard it 46 years ago when I was - dear god, 17! - and I thank Bill and Radio Paradise so much for playing it.
I Agree completely! I was also 17yrs old when this came out! I played it so much that I wore it out & had to buy a new one! GREAT ALBUM!! Thanx RP!
I was 19 when this was released. It blew my mind & still does to this day. I saw Yes live many times & this is incredible live. Jon & Band of Geeks did this live last year at a show I saw in Denver & it was still awesome. Yes has always been one of my top 3 bands. Jon still has his voice & energy. Go see him while you can!