Pickin' On — Battle of Evermore
(no lyrics available)
Comments (33)add comment
I think there's an echo in here...
djidji wrote:
does anybody know the name of the woman that sings background vocals on the LZ version of this song? i always wanted to find out if she did any other stuff because IMO she is amazing.
Sandy Denny
djidji wrote:
does anybody know the name of the woman that sings background vocals on the LZ version of this song? i always wanted to find out if she did any other stuff because IMO she is amazing.
Sandy Denny
djidji wrote:
does anybody know the name of the woman that sings background vocals on the LZ version of this song? i always wanted to find out if she did any other stuff because IMO she is amazing.
That would have to be Sandy Denny.
does anybody know the name of the woman that sings background vocals on the LZ version of this song? i always wanted to find out if she did any other stuff because IMO she is amazing.
maryte wrote:
Hmmm...I'm a Zep fan and I love this song. I also love bluegrass...but I'm just not sure this cover was necessary. After all, the original has some very fine mandolin work in it anyway.
I have to agree. For a cover to be interesting, it ought to introduce something new, e.g., a new interpretation of the song, or else be an exacting replica, in which case really it is a study.
MisterVErb wrote:
sweet. thx, rp. :-({|=
Ditto
WonderLizard wrote:
Wilson sisters' is better.
true dat
I'm a huge LZ fan, but does this version remind anyone of the Deadwood theme in places?
Hmmm...I'm a Zep fan and I love this song. I also love bluegrass...but I'm just not sure this cover was necessary. After all, the original has some very fine mandolin work in it anyway.
I think I'd rather hear Hayseed Dixie if I'm jonesin' for countrified rock covers...
beelzebubba wrote:
LLMikeJ wrote:
no, just a fan...
edit: i looked up your rating of this song and decided that your comment was probably not a compliment, but instead an accusation of being overly critical. well, OK. I guess I didn't like it as much as you did.
i think that soulfulness often comes out a little off-beat & doesn't lend itself well to a metrinome approach
You majored in music, right?
Shesdifferent wrote:
Not sure what to make of this.....probably not, and I'm a Zep fan!
Homage a Led Zep ? Cool ....
Not sure what to make of this.....probably not, and I'm a Zep fan!
beelzebubba wrote:
Calling this blasphemy would imply that "Battle of Evermore" is sacred....
Its sacredness is axiomatic.
beelzebubba wrote:
Calling this blasphemy would imply that "Battle of Evermore" is sacred....
And your point is?
LLMikeJ wrote:
not bad - but in my opinion the representation of the lyrics is a little to sterile/mathematical. i think that soulfulness often comes out a little off-beat & doesn't lend itself well to a metrinome approach (think hendrix - wind cries mary, or anything by gil evans). I think this is where pickin on fails (this is also very much the case with their cover of OK Computer) it's just too clean & straight-laced.
I agree, sounds great, but its too perfect. It lacks the soul... rate a 7
Pyro wrote:
Nicely done, but blasphemy.
Wilson sisters' is better.
Pyro wrote:
Nicely done, but blasphemy.
Calling this blasphemy would imply that "Battle of Evermore" is sacred....
Nicely done, but blasphemy.
sweet. thx, rp. :-({|=
LLMikeJ wrote:
i think that soulfulness often comes out a little off-beat & doesn't lend itself well to a metrinome approach
You majored in music, right?
It's cool, but that high violin repeats WAY too much...
Come on Mike....I got all excited to hear the real thing (like several times this past week) and it always turns out to be fiddle players lately :( hahaha.. I still love the program
laprincessa wrote:
I liked it too!
That's why I uploaded it.
Great upload, LaP!
Leslie wrote:That's why I uploaded it.
This is fantastic!
I liked it too!
not bad - but in my opinion the representation of the lyrics is a little to sterile/mathematical. i think that soulfulness often comes out a little off-beat & doesn't lend itself well to a metrinome approach (think hendrix - wind cries mary, or anything by gil evans). I think this is where pickin on fails (this is also very much the case with their cover of OK Computer) it's just too clean & straight-laced.
This is fantastic!
I'll admit this one made my jaw drop when I realized what band and song was being covered......but it's really well done. The instruments absolutely cover the range and tone of the voices used in the original piece.
This is top-notch musicianship. I have the Allman Brothers one and have heard the Pink Floyd one. Butch Baldesari is incredible.
I imagine that doing a version of this LZ song must not be that easy - aren't the guitar's strings off-key for the song? Love the No Quarter with the voices, though.
Zep meets Blue Grass...can't say I :roll: really like it.
These are fun - the pickin on zz top is great too!
on another note.... holy crap does time fly or what?! can't believe i've been listening to RP for 12 years now...